I know this is a long read, but for anyone that is remotely interested, it is worth a few minutes of your time.


In Katrina I Didn't See Racism, I Saw Brotherhood

by Rabbi Aryeh Spero

In New Orleans, beginning Tuesday morning, I saw men in helicopters risking their lives to save stranded flood victims from rooftops. The rescuers were White, the stranded Black. I saw Caucasians navigating their small, private boats in violent, swirling, toxic floodwaters to find fellow citizens trapped in their houses. Those they saved were Black.

I saw Brotherhood. New York Congressman Charlie Rangel saw Racism.

Yes, there are Two Americas. One is the real America, where virtually every White person I know sends money, food or clothes to those in need -- now and in other crises -- regardless of color. This America is colorblind.

The other is the America fantasized and manufactured by Charlie Rangel, Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, who constantly cry “racism!” even in situations where it does not exist, even when undeniable images illustrate love, compassion and concern. These three men, together with today’s NAACP, want to continue the notion of Racist America. It is their Mantra, their calling card. Their power, money, and continued media appearances depend on it.

Often, people caught up in accusing others of sin neglect to undergo their own personal introspection. They begin to think they alone inhabit the moral high ground. It is high time these men peered into their own hearts at the dark chamber that causes this unceasing labeling of their fellow Americans as “racist.” They may find in that chamber their own racism -- against Whites.

There is only one real America. Beginning Friday morning in Houston, thousands of regular citizens poured into the Astrodome offering water, food, clean clothes, personal items, baby diapers and toys, love and even their homes to the evacuees who had been bused in from New Orleans. Most of the givers were White, most of those being helped were Black. But there was Jesse Jackson, busy on TV, accusing the country of not putting Blacks -- i.e., him -- on some type of Commission he is demanding. Where was he early in the week? Not sweating with others from around the country who had scraped their last dollar to come help. With Jesse, it’s always about Jesse.

After decades of hearing accusations from Jesse, Al, Charlie, the NAACP and certain elitists about how racist America is, it would have been refreshing to hear them for once give thanks to those they for years have been maligning. These self-anointed spokesmen for the Black community lead only when it comes to foisting guilt and condemnation, and not when it comes to acknowledging the good in those they have made a career in castigating.

As a Rabbi I have a message I wish to offer to my fellow members of the cloth, Reverends Jackson and Sharpton: It is time to do some soul searching. Your continued efforts to tear this country apart, even in light of the monumental goodness shown by your White brothers, is a sin.

There are no churches in the world like the American churches. And there are no better parishioners and members of churches anywhere in the world. These churches are saving the day. Their members -- infused by the special and singular teachings of our unique American Judeo-Christian understanding of the Bible -- are, at this moment, writing an historic chapter in giving, initiative, and selflessness. They are opening their homes to strangers. They are doing what government is incapable of doing.

America works because of its faith-based institutions. It always has. That is what makes it America.

So next time the ACLU tries to diminish and marginalize the churches, saying there is no role for religion in American public life, that an impenetrable wall must be erected separating the citizens from their faith, cry out “Katrina.”

Next time the ACLU goes to court asking that U.S. soldiers not be allowed to say Grace in the Mess Hall and that communities be forbidden from setting up a nativity scene, ask yourself: without the motivation of Goodness sourced in Faith, would people offer such sacrifice? Where else does this Brotherhood come from but the Bible which teaches “Thou Shall Love Thy Neighbor as Yourself.”

I saw brotherhood on Fox News, where 24/7 reporters used their perch as a clearing-house for search-and-rescue missions and communication between the stranded and those in position to save. In contrast, the Old-line networks continued with their usual foolish, brain-numbing programming. Those who always preach “compassion” chose profit over people.

The New York Times has utterly failed America. Its columnists could have used their talents and word skills to inspire and unite a nation. Columnists such as Frank Rich and Paul Krugman, however, revealed their true colors by evading their once-in-a-lifetime chance to help and instead chose to divide, condemn, and fuel the fires and poison the waters of Louisiana. In them, I saw no Brotherhood. . The newspaper always preaching “compassion” verifies Shakespeare’s “They protest too much.”

Similar elitists here in the northeast and on the west coast have over the years expressed their view of the South as “unsophisticated” and Texans as “cowboys.” Well, the South has come through, especially Houston and other parts of Texas, whereas, as I write this on Labor Day, the limousine moralizers are lying on east and west coast beaches thinking they’re doing their part by reading Times’ editorials and calling George Bush “racist.” How sanctimonious life becomes when proving you are not a racist depends not on living in a truly integrated neighborhood, but by simply calling others racist.

Like so often in history, facts trump platitudes. Reality reigns. Those who always preach brotherhood, thus far have acted devoid of it. Those who for decades have been accused by elitists of not having compassion are the ones living it. They are: the churches, the military, and the sons and daughters of the South.


[Originally published in Human Events, Sept. 2005]

9/21/2005 9:19:15 AM

i was fine with this untill he started pushing his own agenda

pot meet kettle

9/21/2005 9:29:10 AM

The ACLU wants to ban religion.

Paul Krugman's a communist.

9/21/2005 9:31:50 AM

Quote :

"So next time the ACLU tries to diminish and marginalize the churches, saying there is no role for religion in American public life, that an impenetrable wall must be erected separating the citizens from their faith, cry out “Katrina.”"

those three lines really are ludicrous. I've never seen the ACLU, itself, attack religion. I've seen it attack religion interfering w/ the gov't.

I've never seen the ACLU, itself, say that religion has no role in American public life (as in, not gov't, but not private).

And the same goes for the third statement.

Quote :

"Next time the ACLU goes to court asking ... that communities be forbidden from setting up a nativity scene..."

Eh, if only that were the furthest extend that any level of gov't in the US has ever tried to push religion, then he might have a point. The problem is that gov'ts have done more than that, and that gov'ts will do more than that, and that they will do so only for one or two major religions. Setting up a nativity scene really isn't all that bad, as long as they also set up tasteful and respectful scenes for any other religions that request as such. IE, if muslims want the gov't to set up some kind of "muslim scene" around Ramadan that is as equally tasteful and respecting as a nativity scene, then the gov't should also do so. Of course, the tricky part is what about atheists... I don't know what scenes they could tastefully and respectfully put up, nor would I say that putting up a scene would have to be possible in order for a "religion" to be respected...

On the whole, though, I think he brings up valid points, though his conservative bias about the MSM is rather apparent towards the end of the column.

9/21/2005 10:46:02 AM

http://piratesofneworleans.ytmnd.com/

9/21/2005 10:46:40 AM

Or you could read articles that actually attempt to analyze the racial environment prior to and following the hurricane without trying to elicit an emotional reaction.

http://isteve.com/

9/21/2005 10:57:46 AM

^^^ One of the most even-keeled responses I have ever seen from ab. Definitely did not expect an ACLU defense.

9/21/2005 3:56:08 PM

^ i try to keep you off guard, ya know? I mean, we all know the ACLU is evil, just like flouridation is a communist plot. But i gotta draw the line at blatant lies. Doesn't help my conspiracy theories when I allow obvious lies to go unchecked

9/21/2005 9:26:46 PM

Quote :

"Those who always preach “compassion” chose profit over people. "

So, how about that compassionate conservatism?

Quote :

"Similar elitists here in the northeast and on the west coast have over the years expressed their view of the South as “unsophisticated” and Texans as “cowboys.”"

Kentucky and the football team in Dallas

Quote :

"Often, people caught up in accusing others of sin neglect to undergo their own personal introspection. They begin to think they alone inhabit the moral high ground"

And WTF is this guy doing? Is this the Jewish Pat Robertson?

9/21/2005 9:57:45 PM